Everyone can profit greenly

Heat Pump ROI – First Year Data

Upgrading an old oil furnace and AC unit to a new high efficiency heat pump has been one of the two keys to making my family’s home in PA produce more energy than it consumes (the other of course was adding a big fat solar array). Now that we’ve lived in the house for over a year I thought it would be a good time to look back at the data and see what sort of return on investment (ROI) this heat pump has given us.

After one year we have ended up only spending $477 total to power our heat pump for both heating and cooling. This low $477 annual HVAC spend assumes we pay 10.5 cents per kwh like our neighbors do. In reality though our solar panel system gives us electricity for less than this. I like to calculate that price difference as part of the solar ROI and leave heat pump ROI based on the 10.5 cents all our neighbors pay for power. The estimate for how many kWh’s our heat pump uses comes right from our Bryant thermostat display. I’ve compared the thermostat’s numbers to our total monthly electricity bills to double check it and it seems about right. It also nicely breaks down the estimate based on how it is using the energy, and if you write down the totals every month you can make a nice graph of them all.

Stacked Bar Graph Of Heat Pump Energy Usage
How much energy our heat pump consumed over a year

Looking at this graph you’ll notice a few things immediately. First off, we didn’t turn our heat pump on a single time during the month of September. This is because the weather here in central PA was very nice that month. Opening our windows at the right times and wearing the right clothing was all it took for us to be comfortable all month long. I was hoping that May and June would be the same, but as you can see we did use a tiny bit of electricity on heating and cooling during those months. Maybe we’re just getting weak in our old age?

Next off, you’ll see that we use far more electricity for heating than for cooling and it has a big spike in January. This spike contains a significant amount of “resistive heat” which comes from old style heating coils like the kind that glow in a toaster. When the outside air gets cold enough that the heat pump alone can’t maintain the thermostat’s set temperature these turn on. Getting heat out of these coils can take 4 times as much electricity than it would take to produce the same heat from a heat pump. As the temperature drops a heat pumps efficiency drops as well, so when its really cold out resistive heat coils may only use twice as much electricity to produce the same amount of heat, but you still want to avoid running them as much as you can.

The above graph shows that while the resistive heat is a significant portion of our total energy use in January it wasn’t all that bad, only about 1/4 of the total electricity we used to heat during that month. This means resistive heat produced somewhere between 1/8th and 1/16th of the total BTUs of heat we used that month. I’d say a “bad” heat pump would be one that puts more energy into resistive heat coils than the heat pump during a cold month. What is “bad” of course depends on how cold a “cold month” in your area really is and it’s still important to compare this to how much the unit costs to install. What may be a “bad” heat pump in Pennsylvania might be a great heat pump in Florida.

The Key Metric To Look For In A Heat Pump

When looking at heat pumps there are are few key things to look at. First, and most obviously is the price of the unit. After this you can look at something called the HSPF, which tells you roughly how efficient the heat pump will be over a season. The problem with HSPF is that the weather you have is likely different than the weather HSPF was calculated for. If you live in a cold place like central PA I recommend looking at how many BTUs the unit puts out at 47F and at 17F. Any reputable heat pump should have ah AHRI certification with this information.

The AHRI Certificate for our heat pump

Our Bryant unit is rated at 33.4k BTUs at 47F and 31.6K BTUs at 17F which is a nice small drop. I’ve seen a similarly priced Lennox model that produces 32.2k BTUs at 47F but drops way down to just 21k BTUs at 17F. It will use resistive heat to pump out the 11.2k of BTUs the heat pump can no longer generate when the outside air is 17F. As I explained above resistive heat is so much less efficient than a heat pump use 2-4 times as much electricity to produce the same amount of heat. This means that the resistive heat elements in this Lennox unit can use up to twice the electricity as its heat pump when temps drop very low. Imagine if the orange top to my red bar in January was twice as thick as the red bar below it and you start to understand why I call heat pumps like this “bad” for climates like Pennsylvania.

What About A Ground Source Heat Pump?

One way to avoid the low 17F performance issue entirely is to buy a ground source heat pump instead of an air source one. These take heat from a fluid that runs through a pipe buried underground rather than the outside air. Since the ground has a pretty stable temperature once you get down far enough these units perform about the same no matter what the outside air temperature is. The other good thing about ground source heat pumps is that since they are located inside your home they never need to run a deicing cycle like an air source unit does. These cycles use energy and can sound like someone running a small chainsaw outside your house (though they only run on the coldest days when you’re unlikely to be outside).

The problem with ground source is that burying a long pipe deep in the ground is pretty dang expensive. It can easily add $10k to the installation cost of your installation. As I mentioned above I spent less than $500 running my air source heat pump last year. A ground source unit will probably only use 10-20% less energy than my unit so I could save at most $100/year.

If you invested $10k in a CD with a 1.5% interest rate it would return $150/year so a ground source heat pump would essentially never beat even a very low returning investment like a CD. If pipe installation costs are much lower where you are, or you live in a much colder area (like say, Canada) then it might make sense. But, for most of America I think that air source units have gotten so good that ground source heat pumps should be ignored.

How Much Did The Heat Pump Save In A Year?

I started out noting that we spent only $477 to power our heat pump last year, but how much did this save us? Since we had the heat pump installed before we moved in we can’t answer this for sure. A home energy audit we had done before we moved in estimated that it would cost $1,756/year to heat and cool our 2,000 square foot house with it’s old oil furnace and AC. By that estimate we’re saving $1279/year. But, it was using the average American’s thermostat settings, which are far higher than our own. We set our thermostat lower in winter (65) and higher in summer (79) and do some other tricks like opening our windows at the right moments during the day to save more energy. Taking this into account and looking at our heat pumps data I think we saved more like $1,000 this last year, or around $83 per month.

What’s the total ROI?

To calculate the total ROI you need to compare the up front install cost to the monthly savings. Our high efficiency heat pump had a total install cost of around $15k after rebates. This seems like a lot, but based on the age of the furnace and AC we were going to have to replace them anyways. The median install cost for a new furnace in PA is $4500 while an AC is $4700. That’s over $9k right there. Of course, given how little we use the AC we could probably have gotten away with just using a few cheaper window units instead of a whole house setup. Still it seems unlikely that we could have replaced both for under $5k total. That means that our heat pump cost at most $10k extra. If I invested this $10k in some stock/bond/CD that earned 6% each year then after 15 years I’d have $23,965. If instead I invest the $83.33 I save each month in the same stock/bond/CD that earns 6% each year then after 15 years I’d have $23,275. These are pretty close, and if you’re paying taxes on your capital gains then the $83.33/month heat pump actually wins because with it you are only paying taxes on $8,275 worth of gains, instead of $13,965 (at our current 15% long term capital gains rates this amounts to $853 more in taxes).

Compound Interest Graph for investing Heat Pump energy savings over time

The take away from all the numbers above is that if my investments return less than 6% per year then I am better off having paid extra for my high efficiency heat pump and if my investments return more than 6% then I’m losing. If you look at the return of the S&P 500 you’ll see many recent years where it returned over 10% and maybe you’ll think that a heat pump is a bad investment. If you go back further you’ll also see years where it dropped, 10, 20, even 30%. This volatility is why people diversify their portfolios with safer, lower returning assets like bonds. If you look at the returns of a bond index you’ll see them only returning over 6% a few times over the years. The return from this high efficiency heat pump is both more stable than the return from bonds and higher, what’s not to love?

In the end the exact math on this will depend on the weather where you live, the sort of house you live in, the price you pay for power and your personal thermostat habits. Run the numbers yourself (or leave them in a comment here and I’ll try to help) and see what sort of return you’ll get on your own heat pump. If you’re the sort of person that wants safe investments in your portfolio then you should definitely consider shifting money from those investments into a high efficiency heat pump when your current HVAC nears the end of its life. If you’re a risk taker who owns all stocks then you should compare current mortgage interest rates (around 4% as I write this) to the return you’d get from upgrading to a heat pump. You’ll probably find that expanding your mortgage to include the price of a new heat pump will actually lower your monthly payments. Whatever you do, I hope the real world numbers and analysis I’ve provided in this article can help you to profit greenly yourself.

An Aside on Gas Furnaces

In this post I compare the price of a heat pump to an oil furnace. Per unit of energy natural gas currently costs about half of what oil does. A gas furnace can also be installed quite cheaply if you’re willing to DIY. One thing you will face with a gas furnace is a gas connection charge of around $15/month. You’ll have to pay this all year round, even in the summer months when you are using next to no gas.

I ran the numbers for gas service I had at an old house in upstate NY and the monthly connection fee increased the cost per ccf of gas by nearly 35%! This was for an annual gas use of nearly 550 ccf, which I consider fairly high. If you are in a warmer state, or have a better insulated/air sealed home and use less than this then the % price increase will be even higher. For example, if I’d used only 200 ccf per year then the monthly usage fee would have nearly doubled my cost per ccf. In that case shutting off gas to my house and going all electric could allow a heat pump to provide a higher ROI than gas.

4 Comments

  1. Ken Tarquinio

    I live in San Jose, California where our climate is probably much milder than where you live. The average summer high is in the mid 80 degree range. However, in July and August it can easily reach the low 90 degrees. Very rarely does it ever go over 100 degrees. San Jose is also not very humid. So a slightly warmer temperature is not that uncomfortable. In the winter a “bitterly cold day” is around thirty degrees. Most seasons it never goes below freezing. However, usually nighttime temperatures in the winter are in the 40 or 50 degree range.

    Our 1964 house still has the original gas “80 percent efficient” 100,000 BTU gas furnace. However, I understand that it is probably less efficient than that due to an inevitable loss of efficiency as it ages. I have no air conditioning. However, our house can get uncomfortable for two or three months in the middle of summer. I did a manual J analysis and it showed that my 100,000 BTU furnace was much too large and my ducts are to small for a modern day furnace of that size. In addition, about a third of the house is served by only one duct. That means that the upstairs heats up in a few minutes and the downstairs is perpetually cold during the heating season.

    Electricity is very expensive hear. I have an electric car tariff so my rate is relatively low most of the day (at least for California). As you can see, the tariffs during peak times 4:00 PM to 9:00 PM are outrageously high! Part peak is from 3:00 to 4:00 PM and from 9:00PM to 12:00 AM with rates only moderately better.

    Total Energy Rates ($ per kWh) PEAK PART-PEAK OFF-PEAK
    Summer Usage $0.47925 (I) $0.36876 (I) $0.16675 (I)
    Winter Usage $0.35214 (I) $0.33544 (I) $0.16675 (I)
    Delivery Minimum Bill Amount ($ per meter per day) $0.32854
    California Climate Credit (per household, per semiannual payment occurring in the April and October bill
    cycles)

    Surprisingly, we have lived in the house nearly 25 years and we have never had any problems with our furnace.

    I have been considering replacing my furnace with a new smaller furnace. In part because a newer furnace would would use less energy and partly because a smaller furnace would run for longer periods so that the warm air would be more evenly distributed throughout the house. However, I doubt a new furnace will ever pay for itself.

    I have also considered changing my furnace to a heat pump. However, my concern is that because of my high electricity tariffs, I will have much higher utility bills if I switch from a gas furnace to an heat pump. My reasoning is that much of the heating and cooling would occur during times when peak rates are in effect.

    I have also considered adding a mini split downstairs instead because the ducts downstairs are limited to one register which is completely inadequate. I could then wait to replace the gas furnace until it breaks down.

    I have also considered adding solar.

    Any comments?

    • Profit Greenly

      Thanks for the great comment. 100,000 BTUs for San Jose is crazy, it’ll keep you warm but it’s definitely costing you money. That’s what builders used to do though, don’t put any insulation or air sealing in at all and just throw in a massive oversized furnace. You don’t mention the square footage of your house, but you’d need to be living in like an 8,000 sqft mansion to require that much heating there.

      I think your idea of adding minisplits is a good one. You can save a lot if you feel capable going somewhere like https://mrcooldiy.com/ and DIYing it. If you’re going to have pros do it, you’ll probably spend more doing it in multiple installments instead of one fell swoop, since their time costs money.

      As for CAs high electricity rates, I completely agree with you about them. But CA still has net metering, which means if you install a big enough solar array you won’t pay anything for power. CA also has high solar install prices because of this, but they’re low enough that it’s still profitable to install solar. If you really want to have a huge ROI again the answer is to DIY, but that’s even harder for solar since you need to get on the roof and if you don’t follow all the safety rules you can fall and get seriously injured.

      I think the best answer is to find a company that does solar and heat pumps and pay for a home energy audit from them. That might cost a couple hundred bucks but it’ll give you a far better idea on the ROI of various options. Given that large differences between your peak and off peak power costs you may even want to consider a battery, but if you get a big solar array with net metering you won’t need to. Hope this helps!

  2. John Griffith

    Absolutely love your site/blog, thank you. So glad I stumbled across it.

    Love the way you think — put up a big fat array bc solar is so cheap, and don’t go crazy with changing appliances etc, electrify everything and get more panels if needed…

    We live on a farm in the Upper Peninsula (UP) of Michigan. Cold and snowy. Avg high temp in 20’s and low 30’s Nov-March and only 60’s and 70’s May-Sept. Our big need is heating not cooling, but cooling is great for our rare southern flow with hot muggy days.

    Low sun and lots of clouds in the winter. Long days and much “overproduction” in spring, summer, fall.

    We are installing a 30kW array. As you note, panels and cheap. We have space so are doing a ground mount. Building own racking, single-axis tilt — will have up near 70 degrees in winter to see the sun and shed snow. Free and clear 180 view south from array (on bank of E-W creek). Also will have 10kW of VAWT to help in the winter when it windy and not sunny. Will run 2 EV’s off system, hopefully with V2G capability so we’ll have batteries.

    We have a wood stove with free firewood (375 acres of maple and oak) to take the place of supplemental resistive heat when the heat pump will need help on the sub zero days.

    I have a loader-backhoe, so there is not much extra cost for doing a ground-based heat pump, and we really need one to get 45-50 degree ground heat vs typical single digit or teen low overnight temps (and especially when it goes negative for several days).

    So here is my question, finally: knowing we like to oversize, knowing that it’s a very large but modernly insulated farm house (6,500 ft2 — it’s gonna be a B&B when we’re done), knowing we can cheaply install a ground-based heat pump (and love having it the basement not outdoors all winter!), what make/ model/ size gb heat pump would you point me too? And would there be something like a mini-split in each room/ space that would work with the gbhp?

    Thanks!

    • Profit Greenly

      Wow, your setup sounds like it’s going to be awesome. One caution on the V2G car dream, most current EVs don’t support that, and even if they did you wouldn’t want to do it very often given the number of recharge cycles current lithium batteries support (I do expect we’ll see a bunch more V2G in the next 5-10 years are battery cycle life extends). I also don’t normally recommend ground based heat pumps because of the cost, but I think based on how cold the UP is and the fact that you can dig your own piping area you’re right to choose one. Another word of caution is to make sure you dig a large enough area for the pipes for the HP. You don’t want to dig too small and then find that you don’t have enough heat to efficiently heat your home in winter. As for a specific heat pump, I don’t have a ton of experience with ground based models, but I’ve heard good things about Nordic heating’s liquid to liquid heat pumps. That heat pump is designed to be used with radiant in floor heating though, and if you don’t have that already you might not want to rip up your house to add it (also, it won’t cool your house, but as you note that’s barely needed where you are).

      You don’t mention how the house is heated now, but my initial recommendation is to try and find a heat pump that can tie into that, whether it be forced air, hydronic radiant, or whatever. If that is too hard then mini-splits are always an option, but they’ll be pricey for such a large house, because each split adds cost (they’re pretty easy to install though, so they’re not all bad). In terms of size, that can vary a lot depending on the surface area to volume ratio of your house along with its air sealing and insulation. Considering how much you’ll be spending on this I think it makes a lot of sense to get a professional to come in and do a blower door test and a Manual J calculation for the home. This should only cost a couple hundred bucks and if it lets you size your heat pump appropriately it’ll be more than worth it. In a best case scenario you’d find a company that also sells ground source heat pumps to do the test so they could at least pitch you on the models they carry (though I recommend doing your own research on HPs as well because sometimes installers won’t tell you about a much better model that they don’t carry). Hope this helps. Let me know if you have any other questions, and please do come back and provide an update whenever your project is completed, I’m excited to hear how it turns out! I’ve got some relatives in the UP, who knows maybe some day I’ll get to come up and visit your eco-B&B.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

© 2021 Profit Greenly

Theme by Anders NorenUp ↑